- Sale
-
Brands
Brands A-Z
- Rolex
- Rolex Certified Pre-Owned
-
Watches
Categories
-
Jewellery
By MetalBy GemstoneBy BrandBy Collection
-
Engagement
-
Wedding
Ladies Rings
-
Pre-Owned
By Brand
- Gifts
-
Sell Your Watch
Sell your watch
We will expertly assess your watch and offer you
a competitive and accurate valuation for the
watch you wish to sell to us.Free Instant Valuation
Drop off at any Showroom
Unrivalled Knowledge & Expertise -
Editorial
- Shop by Category
- Sale
-
Brands
- Back
- View All Brands
-
A-Z
- Rolex
- 886 by The Royal Mint
- BALL
- Baume & Mercier
- Bijoux Birks
- Breitling
- Bremont
- BVLGARI
- Cartier
- Certina
- CHANEL
- Chopard
- DOXA
- Duckworth Prestex
- Fabergé
- FENDI
- FOPE
- FRED
- Frederique Constant
- Georg Jensen
- Girard-Perregaux
- Glashutte Original
- Grand Seiko
- Gucci
- Hamilton
- Hublot
- ID Genève
- IKEPOD
- IWC Schaffhausen
- Jacob & Co
- Jaeger-LeCoultre
- Junghans
- Kiki McDonough
- Lalique
- Longines
- Mappin & Webb
- Marco Bicego
- Maurice Lacroix
- MARIA TASH
- Meistersinger
- Messika
- MIKIMOTO
- Montblanc
- Nivada Grenchen
- NOMOS Glashutte
- NORQAIN
- OMEGA
- Oris
- Panerai
- Pasquale Bruni
- Piaget
- Pomellato
- QLOCKTWO
- Rado
- RAYMOND WEIL
- Roberto Coin
- Rolex
- Seiko
- Susan Caplan
- SUZANNE KALAN
- TAG Heuer
- Tissot
- TUDOR
- William Wood Watches
- WOLF
- ZENITH
- Rolex
- Rolex Certified Pre-Owned
- Watches
- Jewellery
- Engagement Rings
- Weddings
-
Pre-Owned
- Back
- Shop All Pre-Owned
- Pre-Owned Home
- By Category
-
By Brand
- Certified Pre-Owned Rolex
- Pre-Owned Patek Philippe
- Pre-Owned Cartier
- Pre-Owned TUDOR
- Pre-Owned OMEGA
- Pre-Owned Breitling
- Pre-Owned TAG Heuer
- Pre-Owned IWC
- Pre-Owned Panerai
- Pre-Owned Blancpain
- Pre-Owned Breguet
- Pre-Owned Chopard
- Pre-Owned Rado
- Pre-Owned Vacheron Constantin
- Pre-Owned ZENITH
- Shop All Pre-Owned
- Gifts
- Sell Your Watch
- Editorial
- My Account
- Wishlist
- Store Finder
- Book an Appointment
- Help & Support
Are in-house movements always better? A debate between Alex Doak and Timothy Barber
By Sarah Jayne Potter | 3 minute read
Has the inexorable rise of the manufacture-made movement delivered improvements in quality? Or is it all about marketing and kudos? Two eminent watch writers, Timothy Barber and Alex Doak, offer their conflicting views. Which do you agree with?
THE CASE FOR
Watches are a lot better made than they used to be. So are cars. So are chairs. So are my poached eggs – since I learned over time that using the freshest eggs, adding a dash of vinegar, decanting the egg into a ramekin before pouring it into the water and serving it on sourdough bread resulted in something that didn’t just fill my stomach but made me immensely happy.
And that’s what an in-house movement does for a watch. It means that your ticker is not just the product of average ingredients smashed together. This is what the Swatch Group’s Nicolas G Hayek realised back in 2002, when he went to war with the industry by announcing a plan to restrict the sale of generic movements to third-party watch brands by the Group’s ETA movement-making subsidiary.
To create a real future, to make a case for itself in a world where perfect timekeeping came cheap, Swiss watchmaking needed to elevate every element of its craft, and brands needed to activate every facet of their ingenuity and creativity. It was the move to in-house movements that attached jetpacks to Swiss watchmaking and sent it into the stratosphere.
Of course, what actually constitutes an ‘in-house’ movement is much debated. But while the many repercussions of Hayek’s 2002 move are still being felt across the industry, it did instigate investment, research, brave decision-making, furious competition and new technological developments. And it has ultimately led to a new generation of movements – in-house, proprietary, manufacture-made, whatever you want to call them – that are better made than previously, with better service intervals, better dependability, greater bang-for-buck, and offering a tempting mix of prestige, fascination and passion all baked in. Just like my eggs.
CREDIT: Timothy Barber is a writer and editor whose work has appeared in The Telegraph, The Financial Times, WiredandQP
THE CASE AGAINST
Why are we seeing high-end watchmakers supplementing ‘manufacture’ supercar movements with less glamorous base movements – described by some as ‘tractors’? And why are mid-luxury brands investing tens of millions of Swiss francs in setting up factories in the first place, to achieve the same?
The answer to both questions is that the Swatch Group was uncomfortable being the only ‘tractor’ builder out there, threatening to throttle its own supply back in 2002. Why should it spend millions constantly refining its go-to workhorses, so other brands could treat its ETA factory like a ‘supermarket’ instead of investing in their own innovation?
But the trouble with buying CNC machines and employing boffins to see PR brownie points and freedom from ETA is the risk that you’ll manufacture a tractor that stalls. After all, you can’t stick a movement on a testbed and accelerate through a lifetime’s performance, as with a new car engine.
ETA’s unglamorously named 2824 and 2892 movements date from the 1950s and 1970s – I think we’d have noticed any glitches by now. Moreover, they’ve enjoyed a certain amount of evolution, such as the Etachron regulator assembly and soonto-roll-out Nivachron antimagnetic hairspring. Even the estimable Rolex only uses a handful of base movements – nipped and tucked with ‘marginal gains’, to borrow a phrase from legendary British cycling coach Sir Dave Brailsford.
And if, with time, the new wave of ‘in-house’ tractors prove to be just as trustworthy as the classics, why pay a premium for something that looks just as industrial? Why not save some more and invest in something that has passed through an additional workshop, found only at the true manufactures – a workshop with a door marked ‘Finissage’.
CREDIT: Alex Doak is a watch journalist whose work has appeared in The Telegraph, Mr Porter and Men’s Health
© 2024 Mappin & Webb
Mappin & Webb is a trading name of Watches of Switzerland Company Limited. Registered Office: Aurum House, 2 Elland Road, Braunstone, Leicester, LE3 1TT, Registered in England and Wales, Company number 00146087. Registered VAT Number 834 8634 04. Watches of Switzerland Company Limited acts as a broker and not a lender and offers finance from Secured Trust Bank PLC trading as V12 Retail Finance and PayPal UK Ltd, Whittaker House, Whittaker Avenue, Richmond-Upon-Thames, Surrey, United Kingdom, TW9 1EH trading as PayPal Credit. Watches of Switzerland Company Limited is authorised and regulated by the Finance Conduct Authority. Our registration number is 308710. Credit provided is subject to age and status, minimum spend applies. Terms and Conditions apply. UK residents only. We may receive a commission if your application is successful, and the amount may vary depending on the product chosen and the amount of credit taken out. Not all products are regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority and FOS protection will not be extended to unregulated agreements. Please note the Consumer Credit Act states that should your purchase / loan amount cost more than £30,000 you will not be covered under Section 75 of the Consumer Credit Act.
*Next day delivery available on most items. See product pages for more information.